The review tool looked like a smart buy. After every job, the plumbing company's customers get a text: “How did we do? Tap 1 to 5.” Fours and fives get a link to Google; ones, twos and threes get a private feedback form that goes to the office. Within a few months the star average climbs.
It feels like smart customer service. It's also review gating, and Google's policy forbids it. Meanwhile one of the techs has started telling customers, “Leave us five stars and I'll knock twenty bucks off next time,” which breaks Google's rules too, and because the discount depends on a five-star rating, the FTC's rule as well.
The legal way to get more reviews is less clever and holds up better over time: ask everyone, the same way, at the right moment, and make it effortless.
What's allowed and what isn't
| Practice | Google's policy | FTC |
|---|---|---|
| Asking every customer for an honest review | Allowed, without incentives | Allowed |
| Sending only happy customers to Google (gating) | Prohibited: no selectively soliciting positive reviews | Its guide for marketers says not to ask only customers you expect to be positive |
| A discount or freebie for leaving a review | Prohibited for any review, positive or not | The 2024 rule bans incentives conditioned on a positive or negative review; its guide says to disclose any incentive |
| Staff or relatives reviewing the business | Prohibited as a conflict of interest | The rule bans insider reviews that don't clearly disclose the connection |
| Review quotas for staff | Prohibited: no asking staff to solicit a certain number of reviews, or reviews with specific content | No separate FTC provision; Google's rule applies |
| Writing, buying or posting fake reviews | Prohibited | Banned, with civil penalties possible for knowing violators |
| Pressuring someone to remove a bad review | Prohibited: no discouraging negative reviews | The rule bans unfounded legal threats and intimidation used to suppress reviews |
The FTC's Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials took effect October 21, 2024. Google's rules are stricter on incentives: the FTC rule targets rewards tied to a particular sentiment, while Google bans rewards for any review. Follow the stricter one.
When to ask, by type of business
The best moment is when the result is fresh and the customer is still feeling it. Pick one trigger per type of job and apply it to everyone, so the timing never becomes a quiet way of choosing who gets asked.
- Plumbers and electricians: a couple of hours after the job is marked complete and paid. The water is back on; the memory of the leak is still vivid.
- Dental and medical practices: the same day as the visit, through a channel the patient agreed to, and never tied to any particular treatment. If a review tool receives patient names, numbers or visit dates, the vendor must sign a Business Associate Agreement first.
- Restaurants: a QR code on the receipt or table card for walk-ins, and a next-morning email for guests who booked a reservation.
Flowchart
One review request per job, for every customer
- StartJob marked complete and paid
- StepTwo hours later, every customer gets the same text with your Google review link
- DecisionDid the customer reply describing a problem?YesA personOwner calls to make it right; the review request is not withdrawnNo
- DecisionStill no matching review after three days?Already reviewedStepNo reminder; thank-you reply drafted in your voiceYes
- StepOne reminder, then asking ends for this job
- A personYou approve replies to new reviews, or let routine thank-yous post by your rules
- DoneEvery customer asked once, the same way
Before and after
Gated requests versus honest requests
Gated survey
- 01Customer rates the job 1 to 5 by text
- 024s and 5s get the Google link
- 031s to 3s get a private form instead
- 04Techs offer discounts for five stars
ResultBreaks Google's policy; reviews can be removed
Ask everyone
- 01Every customer gets the same link at the same point
- 02No rating screen and no reward
- 03Complaints reach the owner for a personal call
- 04One reminder, then no more asking
ResultMore reviews, and ones that hold up
Make it one tap
Google's own help pages for Business Profile owners suggest asking customers to visit a review link or scan a QR code, both of which you can get from your profile. Put that link straight into the message so the customer lands on the review box, not your listing.
- Text: “Thanks for choosing [Business] today. If you have a minute, we'd appreciate an honest review on Google: [link]. And if anything isn't right, just reply here.”
- Email subject: “How did today go?” Body: one sentence of thanks, the link as a button, and a line inviting replies about problems.
- Counter or table card: “Tell others about your visit” with the QR code. Skip “5 stars” anywhere in the wording, and don't ask guests to post while they're still at the table or counter; Google says businesses shouldn't pressure customers to review on the premises.
Send texts only to customers who agreed to hear from you by text, and honor any opt-out. Our guide to texting consent covers what counts.
Replying to reviews, and the healthcare exception
Reply to every review, good and bad. Thank people specifically. For complaints, acknowledge the experience, skip the argument and offer a direct line to someone who can fix it.
Dental and medical practices need one extra rule: never confirm that the reviewer is a patient, and never mention their care, even to correct the record. HHS's Office for Civil Rights has acted on exactly this. A California dental practice, New Vision Dental, paid $23,000 in a 2022 settlement over patient information disclosed in responses to online reviews. A North Carolina dental practice that disclosed a patient's information while answering a negative review was assessed a $50,000 civil money penalty.
Reply templates for everyone else
- Five stars, restaurant: “Thanks, Maria. So glad the short rib landed on your anniversary, and we'll tell the kitchen. Hope to see you both again soon.” Specific beats generic, and naming the dish shows a person read it.
- One star, plumber: “We're sorry the first visit didn't fix the leak, and that you had to call twice. That's not the standard we hold ourselves to. Please call [owner's direct line] so we can look at what happened and make it right.” No excuses, no account details, one clear next step.
- A review you believe is fake: reply briefly and calmly that you can't find a record of the visit and invite the person to call. Then report it through your Business Profile, which Google allows for reviews that break its policies, rather than arguing in public. Healthcare practices should skip this reply entirely, because saying you have no record of someone confirms or denies a patient relationship; use the template below instead.
Setup checklist
- 01Turn off any rating screen that decides who sees your Google link.
- 02Choose one trigger per job type: job closed, visit completed, reservation finished.
- 03Write one message per channel, with no incentive and no mention of stars.
- 04Allow a single reminder, then stop.
- 05Send replies that mention a problem to a person the same day.
- 06Tell staff in writing: no discounts for reviews, no reviews of our own business and no review quotas. Our advice is to skip per-review bonuses too: paying per review pushes staff toward the gating, rewards and fake reviews that Google and the FTC prohibit.
- 07For healthcare, use reply templates that never confirm a patient relationship.
Automating the ask is the easy part; keeping it even-handed is what matters. That's how review requests work in our lead follow-up setups, and what the dentists and plumbers pages describe. None of this is legal advice; it's general information, and state consumer-protection and privacy laws can add their own requirements.
Sources
- Google Maps User Generated Content Policy Help: Prohibited and restricted content
- Google Business Profile Help: Tips to get more reviews
- Google Business Profile Help: Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile
- FTC: Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (Aug. 14, 2024)
- Federal Register: Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (16 CFR Part 465, effective Oct. 21, 2024)
- FTC: Soliciting and Paying for Online Reviews: A Guide for Marketers (2022)
- HHS: Civil Rights Office Enters Settlement with Dental Practice Over Disclosures of Patients' Protected Health Information (New Vision Dental)
- HHS: Dr. U. Phillip Igbinadolor, D.M.D. & Associates, P.A. HIPAA Enforcement Action
- HHS: Business Associates (HIPAA Privacy Rule guidance)