Picture the Tuesday after Presidents' Day at a seven-person tax practice. The shared inbox opened the morning with dozens of unread messages, and more than half say some version of 'Just checking on my return.' Each takes a few minutes: find the client, open the workflow board, see that the return is waiting on a corrected 1099-B, write a polite reply. Meanwhile the phone rings with the same question.
The frustrating part is that every answer already exists. Your practice management system knows exactly where each return sits. The work is carrying that fact from the system to the client, one email at a time, at the busiest point of the year.
Start with a status map
Before automating anything, decide what each internal stage means to a client and who may say more about it. Many firms already track stages in a practice management tool (Karbon, Canopy and TaxDome are common examples) or in a well-kept spreadsheet. Translate each one into plain language.
| Internal stage | What the client sees | Who can say more |
|---|---|---|
| Awaiting documents | 'We're waiting on your 1099-B from your brokerage and your property tax statement,' plus an upload link | Automated |
| In preparation | 'Your return is being prepared. We'll contact you if we need anything.' | Automated |
| Questions for client | 'Your preparer has a question for you,' with the question attached | The preparer writes the question |
| In review | 'Your return is in final review.' | Automated |
| Ready for client review | 'Your return is ready for your review. Please review it and sign the e-file authorization.' | Automated notice; the preparer answers questions about it |
| Filed, awaiting acceptance | 'Your return was submitted to the IRS on March 28. We'll confirm when it's accepted.' | Automated |
| Federal return accepted | 'The IRS accepted your federal return on March 29.' Plus a link to the IRS refund tracker | Automated |
| State return accepted | 'Your New York return was accepted on March 30.' Plus a link to the state's refund status page | Automated |
| Extension decision | Nothing automatic | Partner or preparer |
A few rows deserve care. 'Ready for review' is not 'done': when a firm e-files using the signature authorization, Form 8879, the IRS requires the signed form before the return can be transmitted, so a return waiting on the client's signature is waiting on the client.
Likewise, 'accepted' is not 'refund on the way.' Refund timing belongs to the IRS, whose Where's My Refund tool shows status starting 24 hours after a current-year return is e-filed, so point clients there rather than promising dates.
State returns need their own line, because they're separate submissions with their own acceptance. When a state return is linked to the federal one, the IRS has to accept the federal return first, so 'federal accepted' and 'state accepted' can arrive on different days, and clients will ask about the gap.
How a status question gets answered
Flowchart
Answering “Is my return done?” from the engagement record
- StartClient messages at 8:50 PM: 'Is my return done yet?'
- StepClient signs in to the portal or confirms a one-time code
- StepAssistant reads the engagement's current stage and any outstanding items
- DecisionIs this a factual status question?NoA person'Why do I owe this year?' goes to the preparer with a drafted reply attachedYes
- StepReplies with the stage, anything missing and an upload link if needed
- DoneReply logged on the engagement; the preparer sees it in the morning
The identity step isn't optional. Return status, balances and missing documents are tax return information, and the person asking should prove who they are the same way they would to open the portal. A text or email can carry a nudge ('There's an update on your return; sign in to see it'), but the details belong behind the login.
Proactive updates at milestones
Answering questions is half the job. The bigger drop in email comes from telling clients before they start to wonder. Four messages cover most of the season:
- 01Documents complete: 'We have everything we need, and your return is in the queue.'
- 02Something's missing: exactly what's outstanding and an upload link, repeated on a schedule you set until it arrives.
- 03Ready for your review: a link to review and sign, with a reminder every few days until it's signed.
- 04Accepted: the acceptance date and where to check refund status.
Keep each message short and in your firm's voice. Clients mostly want to know that nothing is stuck on their side; one update per change of stage does that without adding noise.
Before and after
Status questions today vs answered from the workflow system
Today
- 01Client emails or calls to ask about their return
- 02Staff look up the engagement and what's missing
- 03Reply written by hand, often the next day
- 04Missing document requested again by email
- 05Client asks the same question a week later
ResultStaff hours spent relaying what the system already knows
With automated status
- 01Milestone messages go out as stages change
- 02Client asks at any hour and verifies identity
- 03Reply drawn from the engagement's current stage
- 04Missing items listed with an upload link
- 05Judgment questions routed to the preparer with context
ResultFewer status emails; preparers handle the real questions
What only a preparer may say
The line between status and substance is where firms get into trouble. Write it down and build it into the assistant's rules:
| The system can say | Only a preparer says |
|---|---|
| 'Your return is ready for your review.' | 'Your return is done and everything is correct.' |
| 'We're still waiting on your 1099-B.' | 'You don't need that form.' |
| 'The IRS accepted your return on April 2.' | 'Your refund will be $3,140.' |
| 'Your extension question is with your preparer.' | 'We're filing an extension for you.' |
| 'Here's the secure upload link.' | 'You can deduct that.' |
Anything about amounts owed or refunded, deductions, why a number changed from last year or whether to extend is a judgment call. The assistant drafts a reply with the relevant context for the preparer to approve, or tells the client their preparer will respond and roughly when.
Someone has to own that handoff queue. Name one person per day during busy season to clear it, and promise clients a realistic reply window, such as two business days. A judgment question that sits for a week undoes the goodwill the automated updates earned.
Data rules and measuring the result
Status details are tax return information under Section 7216. The regulations let a preparer share return information with another preparer or service provider so the client can see status such as acceptance or refund progress, under specific conditions, so review your setup with counsel. Any vendor in the chain also belongs in the written information security plan the FTC Safeguards Rule requires, with security expectations in the contract. For your firm's specifics, have counsel confirm the details; what's here is general information, not legal advice.
To measure the change, count before you start:
- 01For two weeks before launch, tag every inbound email, text and call that is a status question.
- 02Note how long a typical reply takes and how many prompt a follow-up question.
- 03After launch, keep tagging the status questions that still reach staff, and count those answered automatically.
- 04Compare like with like: the same weeks of the season, since volume follows the deadline calendar.
- 05Read a sample of automated answers every week for errors or confusing wording.
If status questions reaching staff fall and no automated answer was wrong, widen the rollout. If clients keep asking after receiving updates, the messages probably aren't clear about what happens next. Our post on automating client document collection covers the upload side, and our AI chatbots and assistants page explains how we build status answers on top of the tools your firm already uses.
Sources
- IRS: Where's My Refund?
- IRS: Form 8879, IRS e-file Signature Authorization
- IRS Publication 1345: Handbook for Authorized IRS e-file Providers of Individual Income Tax Returns
- eCFR: 26 CFR 301.7216-2, permissible disclosures or uses without consent of the taxpayer
- IRS: Section 7216 information center
- FTC: FTC Safeguards Rule, What Your Business Needs to Know
- IRS Publication 4557: Safeguarding Taxpayer Data