Thursday, 8:20 PM. A caller to a five-lawyer firm wants a divorce lawyer. Before the answering-service operator can slow her down, she's describing her husband's business, the account she believes he's hiding money in, and what she plans to do about the house. The operator types all of it into the message.
The next morning, the conflict check shows the firm currently represents her husband in a business dispute. It almost certainly can't take her case. Worse, it now holds facts from her that could be significantly harmful to her, exactly the kind of information that could disqualify the firm if the husband asks it to handle the divorce.
Why the full story is a liability before the conflict check
ABA Model Rule 1.18 covers prospective clients: people who consult a lawyer about possibly forming a client-lawyer relationship. Even if the firm never takes the matter, it generally can't use or reveal what the prospective client shared. And a lawyer who received information that could be significantly harmful to that person can't represent someone with materially adverse interests in the same or a substantially related matter.
That disqualification can spread to the whole firm. One way to keep it from spreading requires that the lawyer took reasonable measures to avoid exposure to more information than was reasonably necessary to decide whether to take the matter, plus a timely screen and prompt written notice. In Formal Opinion 510 (March 2024), the ABA's ethics committee said that means limiting what you ask, and suggested warning prospective clients to share only what's asked for.
Whether a message taken by an answering service or an AI assistant counts the same way depends on your state's rules and the facts, and states' versions of Rule 1.18 differ. The safe design doesn't change: nobody, human or software, collects the story before the names have cleared.
The minimal-intake pattern
Split intake into two stages. Only the first happens after hours.
| Stage 1: tonight, before clearance | Stage 2: after clearance, with an attorney |
|---|---|
| Caller's full name, and any former names | What happened, in their words |
| Phone, email and best time to reach them | Documents, dates and evidence |
| Names of the other people and companies involved | Their goals and what they've already tried |
| Type of matter, such as divorce, injury or a landlord dispute | Strategy, fees and engagement terms |
| Any court date, deadline or arrest that makes it urgent | Anything sensitive or embarrassing |
| How they heard about the firm | Advice of any kind |
Stage 1 is enough to run conflicts, route the matter to the right attorney and spot an emergency. It's thin on purpose. Add one question for every caller, and especially in family law: “Is it safe for us to call or text you at this number?” If not, confirmations go only by the method the caller chooses.
The opening: “You've reached [Firm]. You're speaking with the firm's automated assistant, and calls are recorded. Before an attorney can talk with you about what happened, we need to confirm the firm is able to help, so I'll ask only a few questions tonight. Please don't share details about your situation yet; an attorney will go over them with you.”
Many callers will start telling the story anyway. The assistant needs a kind, firm interruption ready: “I want the attorney to hear that from you directly. For tonight, can I get the name of the other person involved?”
The one Stage 1 question that needs tailoring is urgency, because “urgent” means something different in each practice. Write your own list with your attorneys, for example:
- Criminal defense: a family member was just arrested, or a first court appearance is set for tomorrow.
- Family law: a hearing date this week, or a caller who says they or their children are unsafe.
- Personal injury: the caller is in the hospital, or an insurer is pressing them to sign something.
- Landlord-tenant: a lockout, or an eviction date already set.
Each item on the list should name who gets alerted and how fast. Anything not on it waits for the morning.
Flowchart
An after-hours intake call, from first ring to consult
- Start8:20 PM: a caller asks for help with a divorce
- StepAssistant says it's automated and asks the caller to hold the details for now
- StepCollects contact details, names of all parties, matter type and any deadline
- DecisionCourt date, arrest or safety concern tonight?YesA personOn-call attorney alerted at once; 911 first if anyone is in dangerNo
- StepAutomated name search of your conflicts database
- DecisionPossible conflict?YesA personNo time offered; an attorney reviews the hit and, if declining, sends the approved letterNo
- StepTentative consult offered from the attorney's calendar
- DoneAttorney confirms in the morning and hears the facts on the consult
Before and after
Full-story intake vs. minimal intake
Full story first
- 01Operator lets the caller explain everything
- 02Message holds finances, admissions and plans
- 03Conflict check runs the next morning
- 04Hit: the firm now holds harmful facts from the other side
ResultA possible disqualification, and an awkward letter
Minimal intake
- 01Assistant asks the caller to hold the details
- 02Collects names, contact, matter type and deadline
- 03Conflict check runs that night or first thing
- 04Facts gathered only after clearance, by an attorney
ResultA clean decline, or a cleared consult
Booking the consult before clearance
Callers at 8 PM want to know what happens next, and “someone will call you” sounds like a brush-off. A tentative consult works better: when the automated name search comes back clean, the assistant offers real times from the attorney's calendar, explains that the time is held while the firm confirms it can help, and says how confirmation will arrive. If the search flags a possible match, it offers no time and says the firm will be in touch the next business day. If your conflicts system can't be searched automatically after hours, every consult stays tentative until someone runs the names in the morning.
- Hold consults on the calendar as tentative, labeled “pending conflicts.”
- Confirm or release each one the next business morning, by a person or from a template an attorney approved.
- If a conflict appears, release the time and send the non-engagement communication without explaining the conflict, since naming who it involves could reveal another client's information.
No legal advice, no promises
Whoever answers after hours isn't the lawyer. The assistant should never say whether someone has a case, guess what it's worth, calculate a deadline or suggest a legal next step. Its job is to take the details and set the appointment. Give it approved lines for the questions it will hear:
- “I'm not able to give legal advice, but I can get you a time with an attorney.”
- “If you have a court date or deadline coming up, tell me the date and I'll mark your call urgent.”
- “If anyone is in danger right now, please hang up and call 911.”
Declined matters deserve the same care. A non-engagement letter approved by an attorney should say plainly that the firm isn't representing the person and that legal deadlines may apply, so they should speak with another lawyer promptly. Most firms already have one; make sure the after-hours process actually uses it.
Data and supervision
ABA Formal Opinion 512 (July 2024) makes clear that the duties lawyers already carry, including competence, confidentiality, client communication and supervision, apply when they use generative AI tools. For an intake line, that becomes a set of questions for any vendor: where are recordings and transcripts stored, who can access them, is the firm's data used to train models, and can a supervising attorney review exactly what the assistant said on any call?
What to require from any intake service, live or AI
- A written minimal-intake script that operators or the assistant follow word for word, including the interruption line.
- An on-call alert path for your urgent list, tested with a real call before launch.
- Approved no-advice lines, and a record of every call you can review.
- Intake records delivered into your practice-management system, not a separate inbox.
- Written confidentiality terms, including a bar on using your callers' information to train models.
Ask for the call summary to travel with each intake record, so the attorney who confirms the consult sees exactly what was said. Web inquiries need the same two-stage discipline; see chatbots on law firm websites. The law firm overview puts intake alongside drafting and billing, and the call script guide turns the pattern above into a full script.
Sources
- ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct: Rule 1.18, Duties to Prospective Client
- ABA Formal Opinion 510: Avoiding Imputation of Prospective Client Conflicts (March 20, 2024)
- ABA News: ABA issues ethics guidance on avoiding conflicts with unretained prospective clients
- The Florida Bar News: ABA issues ethics guidance on avoiding conflicts with unretained prospective clients
- ABA Formal Opinion 512: Generative Artificial Intelligence Tools (July 29, 2024)